We're here to help

With 100s of mortgages to choose from, let us help find the one that's right for you

Application Declined

Browse answers

Posted on 19 April 2010

My husband entered an IVA in 2005 and paid it off early in 2007.  We sold the house and rent.  We have a year to go until his defaults come off of his credit rating.  We are desperate to buy our own house.  He earns £53k and I earn £11k (as I am part time).  We have never missed a mortgage payment or rent payment.  We have a 15% deposit.  Went to an ifa and he told us that Halifax have agreed a Decision in Principle. Yippeeeee!!! We fell in love with a house, offer accepted and now underwriters have turned around and said no!!! I just don't understand. Help!!!!


Halifax are not able to tell your IFA why they have declined your application, due to the Data Protection Act, apart from you have failed their credit score and they would normally recommend that you check your credit file to find out the exact details.  As you are aware of the IVA there may seem little point in doing this, but I would recommend you check what else is registered before returning to your IFA.

It is possible to pass their Decision in Principle because this is based on a restricted credit search which doesn't leave a footprint on your file. This means that you would not be penalised for shopping around for a mortgage, but it does mean that when you do apply and a full credit search is performed, information can come to light which results in the application being declined.

I do believe that you will find it difficult to obtain a mortgage whilst the IVA is still showing and you have a relatively small deposit to put down. If you are able to reduce the amount you want to borrow so that it falls below 75% of the property value it may then be possible to get an underwriter to agree to a mortgage, but I honestly believe that you will have to wait until the IVA falls off the back of your credit record.

I recommend that you speak to your IFA, who has conducted a full factfind and has all your details, about what you should do next.


Your personal mortgage experts

With 100s of mortgages to choose from, let us help find the one that's right for you


0344 346 3672

Categories: Bad credit

Ask your own question


Answers provided in response to Ask the experts are based on the information provided and do not constitute advice under the Financial Services & Markets Act. They reflect the personal views of the authors and do not necessarily represent the views, positions, strategies or opinions of John Charcol. All comments are made in good faith, and John Charcol will not accept liability for them.

We recommend you seek professional advice with regard to any of these topics where appropriate.

Terms & conditions

Our charges are based on two considerations: the loan amount and the complexity of your individual circumstances. We will provide you with a free initial consultation and we will always explain exactly what you will be charged before you choose to  proceed with an application. As we offer a bespoke service our charges can vary. Our minimum fee is £495, (of which a non-refundable £150 is payable when you make a formal mortgage application). The average fee paid by our clients over the last year was 0.24% of their loan value. (For example, if your loan amount is £300,000 our average fee would be £720). If your circumstances are more complex we may charge a higher fee. Our maximum fee is 1.5% of the loan value. (For example, if your loan amount is £300,000, our maximum fee will be £4,500).

These fees apply to all regulated mortgages. Certain mortgages, primarily most buy to let and commercial mortgages, are not regulated. Fees for non-regulated mortgages can vary depending on your requirements and circumstances. Please contact us directly for more guidance.



John Charcol is a trading name of John Charcol Limited and its Appointed Representatives. John Charcol Limited is authorised and regulated by the Financial Conduct Authority. The Financial Services Register number is 665649. Registered in England No. 9157892. Registered office address for John Charcol Limited is 5th Floor, Cutlers Exchange, 123 Houndsditch, London, EC3A 7BU.

The FCA does not regulate some investment mortgage contracts.

Calls may be recorded for training and monitoring.